Translate

Saturday, April 1, 2017

DIY Playlist: The Complete 1966 Live Recordings


Welcome to the first post of 2017, everybody!

While I have completed my coverage of Bob Dylan's unreleased catalog, as it existed in 2016, I thought it might be nice to continue my DIY Playlist series. This seeks to compile the best of Bob Dylan's released work into compelling playlists, separating the wheat from the chaff. When I'm done, I'd like to think that a collection combining my Thousand Highways compilations and my DIY Playlists would represent an ideal cross-section of the artist's work.

With that in mind, let's get into 1966.

That year represented Bob Dylan's largest tour up to that point, geographically speaking. He traveled from the United States to Australia, by way of Hawaii, then on to Scandinavia and the rest of Europe. Happily, his entourage and record company taped a fair number of the concerts for posterity. Leaked versions of these tapes formed the backbone of the earliest rock bootlegs, and led to a 1996 release of the tour's most famous performance at Manchester, England as The Bootleg Series Volume 4: The "Royal Albert Hall Concert."

The 1966 World Tour also represented some of the singer's most ambitious work, artistically speaking. There are dozens of books that could tell you more, but in short, Bob Dylan had evolved rapidly from a singer known for his protest anthems to a poet known for his introspective acoustic songs and then on into a rock musician; this occurred over a span of only three years, leaving many fans either unable or unwilling to keep up. Consequently, while the increasingly experimental acoustic portions of his 1966 shows were met with a reasonably positive reception, the electric portions had coalesced into a truly aggressive, powerful sound and were received accordingly. This dynamic developed further throughout the tour, to the point that Dylan was actively harassing his rowdier audiences by the end of May. The art did not suffer, though, and both his acoustic and electric performances from the year remain some of the most compelling artistic expression that 20th Century popular music would produce.

Bearing that context in mind, I would like to offer my favorite tracks from the recently released complete 1966 Live Recordings. This massive set contains 36 discs of music, and a fair amount of it, while artistically ambitious, presents some sonic issues. The acoustics were not ideal, as rock music in large spaces remained in its infancy, and adding the layer of recording these shows provides a second source of problems. Consequently, only a handful of the concerts present pleasant listening experiences, and fewer still offer a true complete rendering of the night's proceedings - "Desolation Row" and "Visions of Johanna" are frequently incomplete, and "One Too Many Mornings" is often missing its opening moments. I have combed through the collection for the best-sounding, most complete, and most passionate song renditions, and I would like to offer them to you here:

Volume One

She Belongs To Me - Live - Belfast - May 6, 1966
Fourth Time Around - Live - Belfast - May 6, 1966
Visions Of Johanna - Live - Edinburgh - May 20, 1966
It's All Over Now, Baby Blue - Live - Newcastle - May 21, 1966
Desolation Row - Live - Belfast - May 6, 1966
Just Like A Woman - Live - Edinburgh - May 20, 1966
Mr. Tambourine Man - Live - Sheffield - May 16, 1966

Volume Two

Tell Me Momma - Live - Bristol - May 10, 1966
I Don't Believe You - Live - Belfast - May 6, 1966
Baby Let Me Follow You Down - Live - Cardiff - May 11, 1966
Just Like Tom Thumb's Blues - Live - Bristol - May 10, 1966
Leopard-Skin Pill-Box Hat - Live - Bristol - May 10, 1966
One Too Many Mornings - Live - Cardiff - May 11, 1966
Ballad Of A Thin Man - Live - Cardiff - May 11, 1966
Like A Rolling Stone - Live - Belfast - May 6, 1966

As you can see, a few concerts stand out: Belfast, Bristol, and Cardiff. A handful of others exist around the margins: Newcastle, Edinburgh and Sheffield. I had disqualified Manchester and the first night of London, simply because those have received their own unique releases and you can listen to them in their entirety.

With regard to Belfast, this is the earliest night on the tour that shows up on my compilation. It is one of Dylan's most receptive audiences of the tour, and I think that informs his more nuanced, less shouted performances. "She Belongs To Me" does not stand out at any of the concerts, but it is particularly lilting here. "Fourth Time Around," on the other hand, is excellent on most nights, but this one offers some peculiar timing and an emphasis on the song's consonants. "Desolation Row" is more relaxed than usual, with a pleasantly reserved delivery. This version of "I Don't Believe You" received an earlier release on Biograph, and it's easy to understand why - on most nights, the harmonica is too harsh or the vocals are unfocused, but it came together perfectly in Belfast. As for "Like A Rolling Stone," this may be the best version of the song I've heard, aside perhaps from the shattered performance by the singer fifteen years later in Avignon; unlike some nights, he doesn't just hurl this one at the audience, but instead teases it out and plays with the vocal rhythm in a unique way.

Bristol is probably my favorite single night of the tour for the electric set. Much of that is actually down to the recording, as it manages to be raw without being distorted and emphasizes both the guitar and drums better than other nights. The heavier, guitar-oriented songs receive their definitive readings here, including "Tell Me Momma," "Just Like Tom Thumb's Blues," and "Leopard-Skin Pill-Box Hat." In particular, the second of those is one of my favorite performances of the song in its fifty year history and easily the highlight of the eight electric tracks here. "Leopard-Skin Pill-Box Hat" sounds almost like it could have been cut at Otis Redding's Whiskey-A-Go-Go live record, it's so electric.

Cardiff was one of the more surprising entries on my list, as the initial pass hadn't left me with any special affection toward the show; indeed, Leicester and Liverpool seemed better alternatives. When picking the final tracks, though, Cardiff presented a more attractive set of songs that blended well with other nights. The recording had a richer low-end, with the bass more emphasized and the vocals less distorted. Luckily, it also features one of the only versions of "One Too Many Mornings" in which the opening is not missing from the recording. Others have asserted that the Dublin performance of "One Too Many Mornings," with its prominent organ fills, is the best one from the tour, but I believe Cardiff narrowly outdoes it. As for "Ballad Of A Thin Man," something about the recording or acoustic conditions manages to make this song a bit harsh at every stop on the tour - Cardiff was the least objectionable, and so it appears here; my guess is that the unique performing conditions, with Dylan moving to a piano, prevented the established soundboard settings from adequately presenting the song.

Newcastle's tape is a bit harsh, but the rendition of "It's All Over Now, Baby Blue" is significantly more intimate than other nights, with most of the forcefulness gone from Dylan's delivery. While Edinburgh's electric portion is largely distorted beyond pleasant listening, the acoustic portion is lovely - "Visions Of Johanna" benefits from some atmospheric foot-tapping defining its complex rhythm and "Just Like A Woman" is impossibly wistful and delicate, resolving in an uncharacteristically bitter final verse; it cuts to the raw heart of the song in a way few later performances could. Finally, Sheffield represents one of the stranger aspects of the set - for years, the bootlegged version of this concert was the best available capture of the tour's acoustic songs. Here, though, the tape ends up a bit distorted. "Mr. Tambourine Man," though, is among the greatest versions ever performed by the singer, and so it could not be excepted from my compilation; that harmonica solo at the end manages, somehow, to utterly transcend time itself.

As for a handful of things that didn't quite make the cut, the best are "Visions Of Johanna" from Leicester, where it includes very warm, pleasant vocals, "Desolation Row" from Bristol, where it is played faster than usual, "Just Like A Woman" from Birmingham, where it resembles one of the year's magical Hotel Tapes, "I Don't Believe You" from Dublin, where it features a unique slow arrangement, "Leopard-Skin Pill-Box Hat" from Leicester, where the audience chatter at the beginning informs a very aggressive version of the song, "Ballad Of A Thin Man" from Copenhagen, where it is presented as a slick jazz track, and "Positively 4th Street" from Sydney, one of the only deviations from the year's standard setlist captured on a soundboard recording. In general, the Paris concert is rather intriguing as well, as much for the particularly aggressive audience and band response as anything else - sadly, its distortion renders it a less engaging experience than it might have been.

I hope you enjoy this collection - it took a long time to compile, but I think it was worth it in the end. 36 CDs is a lot of music, and having a guide to it is a nice way to experience the breadth of Bob Dylan's artistic achievement in 1966. When you combine this playlist with the two complete shows from Manchester and London, I think you end up with a great cross-section of the year's performances.

Let me know what you think in the comments below, and feel free to offer your alternative suggestions. I'm sure listeners would like to hear opinions on how different nights' performances stack up, especially given how static the setlist remained.

Until next time, keep yourself healthy and listen to some good tunes.

Cheers,
CS

18 comments:

  1. This music is officially released - you buy the songs and then arrange them in the playlist above. Hence the DIY :-)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you. Interesting to see your thoughts on this incredible period!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ah, the best part of this is, my listening of the set has been haphazard, and I've taken long breaks, so other than a not very attentive spin of Newcastle, I've not listened to any of the shows represented here. Thanks again!

    I love the Paris set. Bob's bakedness combined with the hostility makes for a fascinating listen. Whereas his bakedness on the final London show makes that one of the least listenable performances in the set, for me, despite the superb sound.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Funny enough, I actually dislike the sound on the final night. It's fairly brick-walled, as far as I can tell, and seems (to my untrained ears) to suffer from running slow.

      Delete
    2. Hm, that's interesting. I've only listened to it once. By superb, I guess I meant only that it's clear. In any case, the way Dylan drags out the songs is fairly unpleasant.

      Delete
    3. I love the listening experience of that last night, especially after now hearing everything that went before. It is the culmination of an amazing 12 months. Manchester still reigns supreme imo, but Paris and RAH1 are wonderful too.

      Delete
  4. thank s for your come back its a nice way to discover new directions
    I enjoy your playlist
    you do a fantastic work especially in the years of the Never Ending Tour
    Djordj of Montpellier

    ReplyDelete
  5. Don't really see the point in this - to make the compilation you need the full set of recordings - why not just listen to them and choose your own - if you have them you will listen to them. You do a lot of good but this effort seems pointless.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Have to disagree Stewart. I have all the discs but don't have "all the time" to listen and go thru them with a fine toothcomb. I'm still working thru listening to them all, but in the meantime, I tracked down these chosen tracks and compiled "best of" discs. I for one greatly appreciate the effort, and applaud the choices.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes - I also appreciate having an intermediary or guide for this very large collection of performances.

      Delete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  8. Many thanks for this. I wonder what you think of the concert at the Gaumont Theatre in Sheffield - an article that came out in Rolling Stone (sometime before this massive 1966 release, but not too long ago) had said the Gaumont bootleg was one of the best of the tour. Perhaps that did not turn out to be true once every night was available for listening?

    I look forward to further DIY reflections from you!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey there, thanks for the kind words and that's a great question. Prior to the release of the complete 1966 tapes, I would have said that Sheffield represented the best circulating acoustic show. The newly released tapes, though, reveal many more excellent nights of acoustic performances, and reveal that the Sheffield electric set is relatively undistinguished. Consequently, the status of the night has diminished a bit. It's still an excellent acoustic performance - perhaps still the best single night of the tour for the 1st half - but not as noteworthy as it once was.

      Delete
    2. Totally agree. I really wanted there to be a better show than Manchester, but I have to say that I think CBS/Sony got it right. It may have been released because of the "Judas" shout, but it is also the best overall performance imo. RAH1 comes closest.
      What an amazing set though ... I REALLY hope they do the same with '75-'76 in my lifetime.

      Delete
  9. Long time lurker here. Just wanted to thank you for this series. I'm new to collecting Dylan shows and this really helps get oriented. Fantastic work! Are you planning to spotlight the Summer or Fall 2016 or the 2017 legs? If so, I'd recommend the performance of "Tangled Up in Blue" from Wolf Trap, Vienna, VA 7/6/2016. Similar to 2015 in arrangement but enough passion and melodic changes to perhaps be worthwhile. Regardless, my sincere thanks to you for your hard work on this massive undertaking. It's been a pleasure to listen to these compilations as I explore this side of the man's work.

    ReplyDelete